It's been a long time comin'

2019 Update: This group was initially formed to build bridges, explore workable shelter alternatives and to make progress in Boise in the early stages of events related to the 'Cooper Court' tent camp. One of our representatives first approached both Elaine Clegg and then—at her recommendation—the Mayor's office to better understand the city's values and goals, to find areas of common interest and to clarify his personal conditions for voluntary involvement in the effort as a private citizen:

1. That the group not use the effort to pursue long-standing grudges against the city, but instead attempt to work in a complimentary process to provide ultra-affordable shelter and housing.
2. That the group agree not to use the threat lawsuits to force its interests.

In response, Mayor Bieter's office took steps to discredit these efforts, undermine our working relationships with other partners, and even called the employer of the above representative to pressure him to discontinue any public involvement. The Mayor's office subsequently contacted the U of I Architecture Department to discourage their student's involvement in working with the group or designing personal shelters as a practical class exercise requested by their professor.

At the same time, local disgraced Realtor Sean Conner—representing himself as an ally and fiscal representative—defrauded the group, pocketing approximately $100,000 pledged by a donor toward purchase of a building site. While this seriously undermined the original group efforts, the parcel was subsequently donated to LEAP Charities and is now the home of several beautiful homes and families at Windy Court.

We all think that's a great outcome and consistent with our original goals. At the same time, we are shocked and ashamed that the city would still be pursuing Mayor Bieter's unconstitutional anti-camping ordinance rather than welcoming good-faith, informed citizen engagement or investing in innovative and successful models to provide safe, secure shelter options for those able to live independently but who are priced out of Boise's housing market.

See our original organizational mission and description below, then ask yourself why the city worked so hard to suppress and punish those involved. This definitely wasn't #BoiseKind

_____________________________________

Thursday, May 12, 2016So, followers of this project could be forgiven for thinking we had dropped off the face of the earth. It's been a long and eventful winter of ups and downs, but mostly time spent observing, listening, learning and collaborating.

We are still here. And we are stronger and more knowledgable than we were last fall.

The events at Cooper Court last December were tragic and costly. They gave us all pause, but at the same time renewed community interest in the shared challenge of homelessness and energized many to step up and ask how to serve. The outpouring of energy and resources during the Holiday Extravaganza was a great thing to witness.

This is not a tent...or a tiny house.

Some BASC members have been mentoring and learning from a few of the Cooper Court 'refugees,' while others spent time building a prototype structure to test out a few things. We fielded calls from schools, churches, nonprofits and creative community members looking to work toward solutions. We've shared what we learned with others, and we hope they will go forward and create positive outcomes. Most importantly, we've made friends along the way who add practical skills and knowledge to the mix.

One thing we were all clear on: we didn't want to duplicate what others were doing.

The City of Boise and several partners are working toward Permanent Supportive Housing and Housing First. These models are designed to serve those experiencing chronic homelessness—often linked to severe and persistent mental illness and or co-occurring drug abuse. We wish them the best in this effort; these services are desperately needed. Our goal is to complement, not compete.

We have great shelter resources—like Interfaith Sanctuary—that accommodate some individuals and families with children, and the CATCH Program that accommodates families with children who are experiencing homelessness. They are equipped to serve those who require case management and supportive services to stabilize or move forward; services beyond the scope of what a grassroots community group can provide.

But there is an unmet need that we can tackle. We still lack housing or shelter that serves those who can and do hold down a job and/or can live independently, but who just simply can't afford anything. Think of them as economically displaced. We lack private rental housing within reach of those earning minimum wage or living on SSI. These people may not need or benefit from the services and restrictions of a congregate shelter.

So here's the 'elevator speech' to describe what we are up to and the direction we're heading:

Boise Alternative Shelter Cooperative, Inc. (BASC) is a privately funded, grassroots response to the shortage of truly affordable housing. We know government can’t solve every problem, so we have secured land to develop simple, safe and familiar housing types within reach of those experiencing homelessness primarily due to credit barriers or insufficient income. 

These are often the people we see every day; they serve our coffee or food, clean our commercial buildings, and they struggle on wages that can’t support even the most basic needs. The conventional housing market isn’t building housing priced for these individuals because it isn’t profitable. We aren’t out to make a profit; we’re out to make a difference. 

We need to match this generous land donation with support from neighbors and community partners like you to help finance and build housing opportunities for those in extreme need in our community. Can we count on your support? Please contribute today—your contribution is tax deductible and will help you and your neighbors sleep better.

Through a most generous donation, BASC recently secured property and is exploring an option that is both familiar and straightforward—rental housing. We are pretty excited by the prospects and honored by those who have stepped forward to offer assistance and support. Our next steps are to move forward with a traditional development process and raise funds for permits, materials and construction.

We see this as part of the City of Boise's goal to fill the overwhelming gap in low-cost housing.

We are not building tiny houses. We like them, but current municipal codes aren't quite there yet. And we aren't yet building a boarding house...but that's on our minds. For more on this topic, see The Blue Review piece entitled, Planning Behind.

"Waco: The Working Man's Home"

We would encourage developers and officials to consider a modern interpretation of the traditional residential hotel as an efficient use of land and resources to house those at or below 30% of Area Median Income, or AMI. For a great overview of this lost housing resources, see Living Downtown: The History of Residential Hotels in the United States. This doesn't need to involve an entire building; it could be a few floors of this format tucked into other mixed-use vertical development.

With many downtown workers and others embracing a car-free lifestyle and shared social space, the residential hotel could be a reasonable part of our housing mix. Living and working downtown means fewer cars on the road, and their incomes would circulate through the downtown economy.

This will be a community effort and we need all hands on deck. We will need artists, builders, gardeners and cheerleaders. We need people familiar with straw-bale construction and solar options. Volunteers will need food and coffee, and we will need tax-deductible contributions. You get the idea. 

Check back soon for our 'donate' button. Anything will help.

Let's start something good.

Andrew Heben of Square One Villages to speak in Boise

Housing matters: exploring creative shelter and community in a new economy

We're pleased to announce a visit from Andrew Heben, Project & Program Director for SquareOne Villages in Eugene. He will offer a public presentation Thursday, November 19th from 6-8:30pm at the Cathedral of the Rockies, 717 N 11th Street in Boise.

The event is free, but seating is limited. Visit our FaceBook page to RSVP and let us know you plan to attend. Sponsors include the Boise/Ada Homeless Coalition, Boise Co-op, and the Boise Alternative Shelter Cooperative.

If you are unable to view the video at right, click here.

Presentation focus. Eugene is one of many U.S. cities with sizable homeless populations, which has led city and county officials, nonprofits, businesses and even citizens to collaborate on innovative approaches. One such approach is Opportunity Village Eugene, which has received national attention for its social and economic benefits. Andrew will outline the conditions that have inspired this and similar models, the planning, design and collaboration necessary to create a village, and the social component of what is becoming an affordable alternative for those falling though the cracks in our economy and housing market. This is not a forum on Boise's homeless policies.

"A very pragmatic approach that was inspirational to getting people in our community to see what could and should be done."

— Kitty Piercy, mayor of Eugene, OR

Andrew Heben has a background in urban planning and is the author of Tent City Urbanism: From Self-Organized Camps to Tiny House Villages. He has traveled throughout the U.S. to study over a dozen tent cities organized by the homeless, and spent time living at one in Ann Arbor, Michigan known as Camp Take Notice. The book is an expansion of Heben's urban planning thesis at the University of Cincinnati; in a sense it represents an ironic recognition that today's tent cities and homeless camps can in fact be traced to trends in planning and community policing during the 20th century.

"A revolutionary document, a manifesto and manual wrapped in a visionary on-the-ground journey into which the rest of us are invited."

— Tom Atlee, author of The Tao of Democracy

Many of the ideas in his book have been put into action through the co-founding of SquareOne Villages, a Eugene, OR based non-profit organization with a mission of creating tiny house communities for those in need of housing. Their first project was Opportunity Village, which has been open for two years and provides transitional micro-housing to otherwise homeless individuals and couples. They are now moving forward on Emerald Village, which will provide an innovative model in permanent, affordable housing.

"The vision to create a living place of vitality, safety, and human scale is an indomitable urge that likely resides in all people. In fact, history bears out that people create sustainable places and mutual support networks whenever they have access to enough land, resources, and help. That said, Opportunity Village, supported mightily by Andrew Heben, has taken the lead in demonstrating the remarkable inspiring effects and healing power of such a vision in action. The idea that a group of people can undertake democratic processes in such a way that they repair themselves and create a sustainable expression of place will be of interest to everyone." 

— Mark Lakeman, co-founder of City Repair

Who should attend. Planning and housing professionals, social entrepreneurs, policy makers, social and human service providers, homeless and housing advocates and providers, those with an interest in cooperative shelter and housing models, and media.

Local perspective. Seen though a national lens, the number of individuals experiencing homelessness in Boise is comparatively small. Until cities reach a crisis, they are often reluctant to support alternatives to traditional congregate shelters, tenant-based rental assistance vouchers, or multifamily housing with income- or needs-based eligibility.

In Boise and elsewhere, the number of renters spending more than 30, 40, or even 50 percent of household income is significant, and we currently have a shortage of housing within reach of many individuals and families. According to current figures, housing is out of reach for an estimated 5,700 very low income Boise households. This means many households are living less than a paycheck, injury, illness or divorce from homelessness.

Recent articles in the Idaho Statesman illustrate the need for additional housing options for lower-income households.

• Low-income rentals are missing in the Treasure Valley
• Low-income apartments under fire in Star
• The Treasure Valley is in a Low-Income Housing Crisis

The lack of housing diversity in our downtown core has impacts on transportation infrastructure, workforce reliability and air quality as well. Speaking with Idaho Statesman reporter Zach Kyle, local developer Dave Wali and other leaders get this connection.

Downtown workers who cannot afford to live in the city core will increase their impact elsewhere, said [Dave Wali]. “All actions have a reaction,” he said. “It’s more traffic on I-84 and more traffic on State Street. If you live closer to work, you have less impact.”

Read more here: http://www.idahostatesman.com/news/business/real-estate-news/article41751933.html#storylink=cpy

We need to anticipate and adapt to a changing landscape. As Mayor Bieter correctly pointed out in a recent mayoral candidate forum, "...you want to fix the roof while the sun shines." We agree; you don't wait until it's raining to fix the roof, and we shouldn't wait until we have double or triple the current number of people on the streets to explore workable housing and shelter alternatives.

We have now entered a new normal.

TEDx talk by Pastor Dan Bryant, Executive Director of SquareOne Villages

Dream big with tiny houses

Pay For Success / Permanent Supportive Housing / TransForm Idaho Homeless Forum

The Boise Weekly has been devoting significant time and ink to challenges around homelessness.

It's helpful to understand all the efforts being undertaken by the city and others to cultivate both short- and long-term solutions. The City of Boise is pursuing permanent supportive housing and a 'Pay for Success' model to incentivize third parties to create housing and and services (like case management or counseling) for persons currently experiencing homelessness. Read more on that here.

Support for the city's long-term goals. The members of BASC fully support the city's efforts to create permanent supportive housing, as well as expanding housing types and price points that offer affordability and stability to people at all income levels. We encourage other stakeholders to support their efforts as well.

A citizen-driven, private grassroots is a natural response to perceived needs involving homelessness, and BASC efforts are informed by successful faith and community partnerships in the NW that are proving effective and affordable for economically displaced people. These are folks for whom local housing is simply out of reach and for whom congregate shelters may not be the best option.

We appreciate that the city of Boise (and any city) would have legitimate questions about any alternative approach. That said, our efforts should not be construed as critical of others, including city leadership. Just as no two people are identical, the solutions needed to stabilize displaced individuals will naturally be diverse. Incivility by others towards city in the press or public does not represent BASC, it's active members or values.

We can disagree without being disagreeable, and we know that today's perceived adversaries may be tomorrow's allies. Open and honest evaluation of ideas and strategies is what makes a democracy work.

October 7th Homeless Forum. George Prentice also served as the moderator for a well-attended forum on homelessness sponsored by Transform Idaho. Panelists included Police Chief Bill Bones, Homeless Coalition President Barbara Kemp, Diana Lachiando from the Mayor's Office and Ada County Commissioner Rick Yzaguirre. Read more about that discussion and view some video from the evening here.

Many in the audience posed questions on the 3" x 5" cards provided and were confused when the questions didn't surface in the discussion. Following the Forum, the needs of Cooper Court residents have been assessed by volunteers coordinated by CATCH. This is a critical step to inform efforts going forward.

Andrew Heben Presentation. The event on November 19th is not a forum on homelessness in Boise; it is a presentation by a widely recognized author and expert on the rise of tent cities and tiny house villages, and on the planning, political, environmental, economic and social implications of these constructs. This is a national and international conversation; it is by no means about any one community.

Listening Session. Members of BASC and Transform Idaho are planning a 'listening session' in early December with the goal of giving folks without housing a chance to speak up in their own words.

Our long-term goal is for the many people and organizations of conscience to work more collaboratively, finding space to address diverse community needs while making best use of taxpayer dollars and community capacity both private and public.

Housing as a Human Right

Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states:

1. Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control

This pretty much sums things up.

'Tiny Houses' We Are Not (but we like them)

These are not Tiny Houses. Tiny houses have their own bathrooms and kitchens, they feature plumbing and electrical service and often use propane appliances. Some are built on trailers or are classified as recreational vehicles; others are placed on fixed foundations and built to local codes, where allowed. Typically tiny houses may range from under 100 square feet to a few hundred square feet. Material costs for a DIY tiny house often start at $6,000 to $7,000 and can go much higher.

The tiny house movement is here to stay; it is equally attractive to people with money who are interested in downsizing, simplifying and reducing their environmental footprint, as well as folks who simply can't afford the scale and style of housing society says we 'require.'

While there are community and economic development reasons to create both physical and regulatory space for tiny houses, we also see a value in more economical options. The structures we'd like to experiment with could best be thought of as 'detached guest rooms.' They don't have their own kitchens or bathrooms, but those amenities are shared to create efficiency. The primary purpose of the personal shelter is to provide privacy, personal safety and security, along with protection from the elements and predators.

There are great examples of tiny houses and villages, including Quixote Village in Olympia, WA. The net cost per unit (accounting for cash, infrastructure and in-kind investments) exceeds $100,000.

A more local example intended to house individuals experiencing homelessness is the Boise Tiny Houses for the Homeless project.

U of I Students Work on Designs for Homeless Housing

Harrison Berry wrote a nice article in the Boise Weekly on the topic of personal shelters. It should be pointed out that the U. of I. is agnostic on the Cooper Court or homeless coordination per se; this was merely a student exercise in addressing the most basic human needs for personal safety and protection from the elements through design. These concepts could easily be adapted to provide shelter for any internally displaced individuals or families, whether as a cause of natural or economic factors.

Design by U of I student E. Marek. Materials cost = $499.20

Great effort by the architecture students; they were able to tour Cooper Court and interview residents, some of whom were able to see the presentation and results of those interviews. Good luck to everyone involved! With any luck and an acceptable site, we may be able to translate a few of these designs into useable shelters.


There are many approaches to providing housing and shelter options, the city is moving forward on a few fronts, as are several area providers and partners. The ultimate goal is to find safe, healthy places where people can find the stability needed to move forward.

Read the full article here.